Shimrit Dror

Learning strategies and skills for children, teens, students and adults

Learning strategies and skills for children, teens, students and adults

Weighted Blankets – Are They Really a Solution for Attention Difficulties?

Weighted blanket for attention difficulties

In this post I write from my personal and professional experience about the weighted blanket as one of the solutions offered for easing attention difficulties.

First, I want to put this on the table right away:
I see a lot of ads presenting the weighted blanket as a solution for ADHD.
There’s no such thing.

If there’s a very mild attention difficulty that stems entirely from poor-quality sleep, a weighted blanket might change the situation completely.
But in all my years in the field, I have never met a case where that was the whole story.

Second, it’s important for me to note that every article, post or video I publish aims to share knowledge at the neurological / brain / physiological level.
There’s a sea of knowledge about attention difficulties, and in my view one of the reasons people keep searching for solutions is that they never reach a deep understanding of the source of the difficulty.
It matters to me to make this understanding accessible to parents, teachers and educators.

That’s why you won’t find quick, short explanations here.
In a time when everything is instant, I choose to make knowledge thorough and in-depth.

At the same time, for those who find it hard to make time to read and go deeper, I’ll give you the answer about the weighted blanket right here.
And anyone who wants to understand the neurological side is welcome to keep reading.

For me, the weighted blanket was one of the very few things I tried that split my life into before and after.
In my course on natural brain training to improve attention and focus, I talk at length about the role of sleep – and about the fact that while we sleep, the brain is actually working very hard.

During sleep, the brain carries out many maintenance processes that are supposed to let it work “quietly” during the day.
At night, the brain is essentially preparing itself for the day’s work.
If we were to put it into words, the brain is saying something like:
“Now, while this person is asleep and doesn’t need me for conscious activity, I’ll clean, organize, sort and synchronize systems – so that tomorrow I’ll have the strength to think, regulate emotions, organize the day and cope with the world.”

When sleep isn’t good quality, the brain can’t complete the tasks it’s responsible for at night.

In the world of coping with attention difficulties there are so many solutions.
And I admit it – after trying so many tools, you reach a point where you’re simply tired of trying.

That’s exactly why I put off buying a weighted blanket for years.

The feeling of "shooting in every direction"

I had already been through quite a few attempts.
(And as an aside: the meaningful breakthrough for me and for my clients came from combining neurofeedback with brain training from the field of functional neurology.)

In the end I decided to try it – and my life is divided into before the weighted blanket and after it.
Today I have a weighted blanket at home and at my parents’ place, and when I travel to hotels in Israel, I take it with me.
That’s how much it has improved my sleep quality!

But here comes the important nuance

Attention and focus difficulties can stem from many different neurological sources.

So even though for me it felt like striking gold, it was clear to me that what worked for me wouldn’t necessarily work for everyone.

And that’s exactly what happened.
Some of my clients, whom I recommended try it, experienced a significant improvement in sleep quality.
Some didn’t understand what was so special about it.
And for some it was even bothersome, and they stopped using it.

It isn’t a cheap product.
So it’s important to me to say honestly: there are cases where it can help, and cases where it can’t.

If you really want to understand, you need to ask:
What is the source of the difficulty?
Is sleep the heart of the matter, or just a small part of the picture?

A little neurology – for those who want to go deeper

Our brain is made up of many areas and networks. Think of a factory with many departments: only when every department works efficiently can the factory make a profit. Our brain is the same – it’s made up of different areas, and each area has its own role.

One area worth knowing is the prefrontal cortex: a region at the front of the brain, near the forehead, involved in attention, impulse control, organization, planning, morality, empathy and even estimating time (yes, we have a built-in “time app” in the brain).

When this area doesn’t work with balanced, precise electrical and chemical regulation, we experience difficulties with attention, management and organization.

Beyond it, there are also sensory-motor networks responsible for movement and for regulating movement.
The brain doesn’t only produce movement – it also invests energy in inhibiting movement.

There are neural inhibition mechanisms whose purpose is to reduce restlessness and keep the body stable during sleep.
In certain stages of sleep, especially REM sleep, the brainstem even activates a mechanism of partial physiological paralysis to keep us from actually acting out what we’re dreaming.

When these inhibition mechanisms aren’t balanced, we may see excessive movement, restlessness and frequent waking.
In such a state, the brain has to invest energy in regulating the body and is less available for the deep maintenance processes of sleep.

And this is where the weighted blanket comes in.

A weighted blanket works through a mechanism called Deep Pressure Stimulation.
The even pressure on the muscles and joints activates sensory receptors in the skin and the musculoskeletal system.
This sensory information travels through the spinal cord to the brainstem and to limbic areas involved in regulating arousal and stress.

The possible result is a gradual shift from a state of sympathetic arousal (alertness, Fight or Flight) to a parasympathetic state: a state of calm.

Studies also point to a possible effect on serotonin and melatonin (linked to calm and falling asleep) and to a decrease in cortisol (a stress hormone).

In other words, the blanket has a deep effect on more basic, older regulatory systems in the brain.

But it doesn’t “fix” every neural mechanism.
If the source of the sleep difficulty isn’t related to over-arousal of the nervous system, its effect may be minimal.

So, once again

The question isn’t “Is a weighted blanket good?”
The question is:
What is the dominant mechanism disrupting sleep and attention for that particular person?

Based on your answer, drawing on what you know about your own situation or your child’s, you’ll be able to tell whether it’s right for you.

Dear readers 💜
I invite you to receive, as a free gift from me 💜
the first lessons of my "Learning How to Learn" course

Accessibility Menu